As graduation season comes into full bloom, high school seniors are finding out who won their class favorites. The “Most Likely to Succeed,” superlative probably went to the valedictorian, while “Class Clown” went to the next Amy Schumer. But, we wanted to know who would be deemed “Most Likely to End Up With A Cat At Age 50″ within our favorite bands.

So, we asked The Maine who among Kennedy Brock, Pat Kirch, Jard Monaco, Garrett Nickelsen, and John O’Callaghan would win such a title. The answer may surprise you. Even in rock bands, there has to be a “Best To Take Home To Mom and Dad,” right? After quite a pause, Pat and Kennedy revealed their pick.

Watch the video below to find out who would be best at karaoke, and would sing a Backstreet Boys song to prove it.

The Maine‘s latest album, American Candy is a far departure from their previous record, Forever Halloween. With a little less than two years in between albums, American Candy has a more uptempo and carefree vibe than their previous installment. The fifth album did a complete turnaround from the “darker” sound they experimented with in Forever Halloween, as guitarist Kennedy Brock described to us. “It’s always kind of our goal to go into the studio and do something that feels fresh and new,” Brock said about the change.

We sat down with drummer Pat Kirch and Kennedy just at their start of their “American Candy Tour” in April and talked about their social media black out during the recording of “American Candy,” 90s influences in their music, and much more. Check it out below.